Skip to main content

Does being a writer determine your politics?

 I get a newsletter from a Substacker who will remain nameless. "They" are progressive politically, but I have enjoyed and been moved by their writing.  They train others in writing as wel.  

The title of this week's is "How Writers Can Oppose Trump's Bad Policies."

Does this imply Biden had no bad policies?

Does this imply a writer can't support Donald Trump (not that I do, so much, but it seems to be an implication or assertion without support)? 

Does one have to be progressive in politics to be a good writer? Is anyone who supports Trump incapable of good writing? Does it diminish our humanity or creativity or something?

This writer, who is a naturalist and environmentalist, says that their goal is to make life better. I appreciate that. I can see how from their perspective there might be a massive, unbridgeable disconnect between support for Trump and a better ecology (that word is a clue to the writer's identity, to those who know Southern literature; that book is a masterpiece, by the way). 

Perhaps. Perhaps the issues are complicated, require nuance, require parsing such that we have to reject some things and not others, rather than embracing something wholesale without thought. 

I am reminded of something Walker Percy wrote to the liberals of his day. https://www.firstthings.com/web-exclusives/2023/04/walker-percy-and-abortion

“If I had anything to say to the liberals,” Percy told one interviewer, "it is that I agree with them on almost everything: their political and social causes, and the ACLU, God knows, the right to freedom of speech, to help the homeless, the poor, the minorities, God knows the blacks, the third world—their hearts are in the right place. It’s actually a mystery, a bafflement to me, how they cannot see the paradox of being in favor of these good things and yet not batting an eyelash when it comes to destroying unborn life."

As writers we should instead reserve the right to disagree and call out both sides when they abandon American citizens to terrorists, find no other good in the world than the extensive of abortion, and when they are narcissistic leaders who refuse to help an ally or when they nominate people for important positions with a view of misplaced loyalty over competence (this covers both sides, thank you). 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Why to Read Fiction, Idea #27: Empathy, anyone?

The Idea #27 is tongue in cheek.  But these are some ideas about writing fiction, which I have done in ten novels (and counting), a dozen short stories, and two produced plays (I know, not exactly the same).  Background: In 2015 a colleague and I wrote an open educational resource public speaking textbook for a grant provided by our University System. We didn't realize at the time that it would go viral and be used all over the world within a few years. There are two reasons for that: it is good (as good as anything on the market) and it is free, although only in digital form. Check out www.exploringpublicspeaking.com for it. We also didn't know at the time that my co-author would die at 39 in 2016. I still miss him. Back to the point, I receive requests for the test banks every other day, and this morning I received one from Pennsylvania. The writer had a signature line: "Reading fiction is important. It is a vital means of imagining a life other than our own, which in t...
Post a Comment
Read more

Books I Have Read Lately

 Retirement means more time to read.  One Blood , by Denene Millner. This book and author won the Townsend Prize for Fiction 2025 and therefore beat me as one of the other nine finalists. She deserved it for her dramatic and exotic style; mine feels pale in comparison. I have to admit, I have timed out on it when I got to the third main character's story. It starts with a Black midwife in 1950s/1960s Virginia, who is imprisoned for not lying on a birth certificate about a "white" baby's racial identity. The baby is clearly part Black, meaning either the family had Black ancestors or the mother had a lover (I'm not entirely sure about that). The midwife's daughter is brutally murdered by her lover and in this chaos, the granddaughter is spirited away to New York in a wooden box. (Why I am not sure--New York makes sense, because a relation lives there, but why she couldn't just be put on a train, I'm not sure. I imagine Black people could ride trains in ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Keeping Up Appearances? David's Surprise Anointing to Be King

  Have you ever watched the show, Keeping Up Appearances? What it is. A comedy about a British woman who wants to be thought of as very high class even though her family is low class. Her name is Hyacinth Bucket but she pronounces it Bouquet. She wants everything perfect but her family works against her, and her neighbors run from her. We all know someone who wants to keep up appearances, and sometimes we do. In our everyday life, we depend on our eyes and we automatically trust them, at least at first, and we often don’t look closely or below the surface. Like puzzles. But we know that appearances can be deceiving, even though they catch us. So I wanted to show this video I saw recently because it’s disturbing but informative. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FERa1AI2EK8 AI has gotten far better on making these deep fakes—videos that are not of anyone but totally generated by the software. Even though they look like someone, they are not. Of course, it is stealing fro...
Post a Comment
Read more