Skip to main content

January 24: James or Christie?

I don’t want to make a choice here. I only want to explore the differences.

P.D. James wrote from the perspective of a career in health care administration and UK bureaucracies, as well as Parliament. She was not as prolific as Christie in terms of books.

Agatha wrote from her experience in WWI as a nurse working in a pharmacy. Poisons proliferate in her stories.

PD brings us a wider range of people in English society, and more recently—1960s through 1990s. They are less stock and are more likely to be three dimensional. Especially her main detective, Adam Dalgliesh. He is a poet, brooding at times yet fair and egalitarian, resolute to find the murderer but compassionate. She tends to have a formula of three murders, sometimes four, occurring in each book.

Some of Agatha’s stories are 100 years old, and in their originals some racist material can be spotted. It seems that she fixed her sights on the gentry class in English, which was declining. So many of her stories have to do with people killing for inheritances they are waiting on in penury, leading me to think, “Why don’t these people just go get jobs and support themselves rather than waiting on Aunt Gertrude to die or get murdered conveniently?”

Baroness James took more of philosophical and social commentary stance, as her futuristic novel The Children of Men shows.

Both women had sad first marriages. Agatha’s husband cheated on her and left her. Phyllis James husband suffered from mental illness after World War II and died early.

I was happy to find the recent Dalgliesh series, although after Season 1 I have to pay for it. Well, they say there is a free trial, but I am very allergic to free trials of media.

I am sure Agatha’s descendants have enjoyed far more royalty money than P.D.’s.

All that says, as a writer I prefer James, but Agatha has a bigger range and following. It seems an oxymoron to say we are blessed with both of these talented tellers of tales about murder. Blessed, maybe not, but we definitely enjoy them.


Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Birdwatching

 Whose world is this, anyway? My husband came out to the deck where I was reading, thinking, and taking long pauses to listen to birds and watch them visit the feeders. Nala and Butter were keeping the the squirrels away. The cardinals, like kings, were making sure they were fed first but wrens, sparrows, finches, robins, swifts sat in the trees calling and cackling. My Cornell Labs app has identified 18 in 18 minutes, some new ones included. “How interesting that God made all the birds have distinctive calls,” I said. “But I guess they are calling to their own kind, their mate and children.” “Do you think they are talking to each other?” he said. “Not like we do, no communicating, but signaling.” “I thought they were singing for us.” We laughed about that; our human-centric, self-centered view of things takes over. “They sing and make noises when we are not here, so it’s not for us. If they are singing for anyone, it’s God.” I had read Samuel’s speech to the nation in I Samuel 12,...
Post a Comment
Read more

Keeping Up Appearances? David's Surprise Anointing to Be King

  Have you ever watched the show, Keeping Up Appearances? What it is. A comedy about a British woman who wants to be thought of as very high class even though her family is low class. Her name is Hyacinth Bucket but she pronounces it Bouquet. She wants everything perfect but her family works against her, and her neighbors run from her. We all know someone who wants to keep up appearances, and sometimes we do. In our everyday life, we depend on our eyes and we automatically trust them, at least at first, and we often don’t look closely or below the surface. Like puzzles. But we know that appearances can be deceiving, even though they catch us. So I wanted to show this video I saw recently because it’s disturbing but informative. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FERa1AI2EK8 AI has gotten far better on making these deep fakes—videos that are not of anyone but totally generated by the software. Even though they look like someone, they are not. Of course, it is stealing fro...
Post a Comment
Read more