Skip to main content

More on Artificial Intelligence-Generated Writing

 Quoting Gil Crouch, Joel Miller writes:

“The idea of the gift economy is fundamental in how we create social bonds, form and maintain relationships, deep or just transactional, such as with a brand through marketing activities like advertising,” says Crouch. “Writing poems, sonnets, novels, non-fiction books, articles, blog posts, all are forms of this moral and social gift-giving. The writer creates a book and publishes it because they want to tell a story. When we read the book, we are reciprocating the gift by reading it.”

A piece of writing is a pact between the writer and reader. It’s a contract, and we feel betrayed or cheated when we discover the writer didn’t invest their work with the effort, intent, or skill we expected. It’s like buying a bag of chips and finding out the package is mostly air. We feel ripped off.

Deepening this dynamic, Ruth Gaskovski and Peco recently discussed the “I” of the creator. “There is an ‘I’ behind a work of art,” they write. Ruth mentions her first encounter in the Louvre with Monet’s painting The Luncheon, examining the brushstrokes. “Even though I was well over a century removed, I felt that his hand was somehow within my reach, hovering in the same physical space that I was now occupying.” She was communing with the artist’s residual presence in the work.

But what if there’s no real artist involved? What if the giver is passing off something other than the gift we assume we’re getting? Our answers to those questions are behind why a book gets canceled or a deal falls through when AI use is flagged or suspected; it’s not just about cringy writing or copyright issues (AI-generated prose can’t be copyrighted, so it buggers the publishing model). It’s about the feeling that there’s no “I” on the other side of the exchange. That’s part of the let-down when we find an artist has used AI in the production of a work.r

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Books I Have Read Lately

 Retirement means more time to read.  One Blood , by Denene Millner. This book and author won the Townsend Prize for Fiction 2025 and therefore beat me as one of the other nine finalists. She deserved it for her dramatic and exotic style; mine feels pale in comparison. I have to admit, I have timed out on it when I got to the third main character's story. It starts with a Black midwife in 1950s/1960s Virginia, who is imprisoned for not lying on a birth certificate about a "white" baby's racial identity. The baby is clearly part Black, meaning either the family had Black ancestors or the mother had a lover (I'm not entirely sure about that). The midwife's daughter is brutally murdered by her lover and in this chaos, the granddaughter is spirited away to New York in a wooden box. (Why I am not sure--New York makes sense, because a relation lives there, but why she couldn't just be put on a train, I'm not sure. I imagine Black people could ride trains in ...

Poem of the Day

 Vision Driving on a busy highway designed to relieve traffic on a busier one, My glimpse lands on a mound of color in the turning lane ahead. I see a human body. That is not what it is, but what my mind perceives. The envisioned body is wearing a bathing suit, and it is female. It is deceased of course; half of it is legs with pale skin, half is a mix of red and blue and yellow. My heart tightens; my eyes, which need to look elsewhere, are captured. I go under a traffic light and the pile transforms into a towel twisted into some elongated shape, either thrown and dropped from a vehicle. Why did I see a corpse in the way of oncoming cars? Are my eyes failing me? My corrective lenses? My imagination? My expectations? Is it too much true crime television? Who knows? And what if I had seen a human form that metamorphosed into a towel? --- This is more about a concern of aging, not to show my poetic skill. I write one or two (or fewer) poems a year. ...

The Temple in the Old Testament, New Testament, and Eternity

 Lesson August 11, 2025, I Kings 5 through 8: Solomon builds and dedicates temple The literature called this lesson, “Work with Wisdom” as a follow-up to Solomon’s request for wisdom. Despite Solomon’s failures we discussed last week, this passage and the ones in II Chronicles 2-7 (same information but some additions) tell of his highest achievement, the building of the temple that came to be known as Solomon’s temple, which was destroy in 586 B.C. Since it was completed in 957 (or so) BC, it stood for almost 400 years. It is distinguished from what were called: Zerubabel’s temple, finished in 516 B.C. after the exile (70 years after destruction of Solomon’s temple). From Got Questions.org “As the second temple was being built, there was a group of Jews in Jerusalem who were rather disappointed. Older Jews who recalled the size and grandeur of the first temple regarded Zerubbabel’s temple as a poor substitute for the original. To their minds, it did not even begin to compare w...